All Rentals

Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY Between $26,000 and $45,000

(1 - 15 of 227)
  1. Escape to this charming 1790s Whaler's Cottage in Sag Harbor Village for the ultimate summer getaway. This stunningly updated home boasts a spacious open floor plan with Scandinavian design featuring a dual-sided fireplace that divides the living ...
    Mala Sander ·19 hours ago on RealtyWW
  2. Sited in the highly sought-after Amagansett Lanes on a sprawling half acre +/-, one can find an impeccably renovated 4, 000 +/- sq. ft. turn-of-the-century home that combines a wonderfully understated aesthetic with all the modern comforts that on...
    Beth Felsen ·1 day ago on RealtyWW
  3. Discover the ultimate summer escape with this brand-new cedar shake beach house, ideally situated on Little Peconic Bay. This stunning property boasts 125 feet of private sandy beach, offering unparalleled views of the bay and the charming sailboa...
    Carol Szynaka ·20 hours ago on RealtyWW
  4. Just moments outside of the Village of Sag Harbor and up the road from Long Beach, this 4 bedroom beach house is new to the rental market. The main level of the home is centered upon the updated chef's kitchen which is spacious and well equipped. ...
    Julie Masson ·21 hours ago on RealtyWW
  5. This charming Sag Harbor Village Cottage is set on 0.11 acres with 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths and separate studio with powder room. The first floor is comprised of a living room with fireplace, sitting room, den, dining room with fireplace, full bat...
    Beate Moore ·1 day ago on RealtyWW
  6. This well kept Sagaponack home is set on a beautifully landscaped 4.8 acre lot and designed for easy entertaining, Conversation areas inside and out are plentiful. A new modern custom kitchen offers quartz counter tops, stainless steel appliances ...
    Barbara A. Lester ·1 day ago on RealtyWW
  7. Set south of the highway and newly renovated, this historic home was originally a potato barn and then an iconic fish market before being converted into a stunning modern three-bedroom, 4.5 bath compound. Less than a mile from Amagansett's famed I...
    Elizabeth Carey ·1 day ago on RealtyWW
  8. AVAILABLE NOW Gorgeous Sag Harbor East Hampton Home w/ Outdoor Oasis on 3+ Acres Welcome to this beautiful 3200 square foot home with 4 bedrooms (3 bedrooms upstairs, 1 bedroom downstairs) and 3 Bath. This spacious home was masterfully finished an...
    Stacey Pitts ·2 days ago on RealtyWW
  9. Located in the historic part of Springs, this 1800s farmhouse offers an idyllic retreat. The first floor boasts a large living room with fireplace, separate dining room, den with a queen-sized sleeper sofa, and a half bath. The open kitchen is wel...
    Heather L Saskas ·3 days ago on RealtyWW
  10. Wonderful Southampton village location close to shops and beaches. This four-bedroom, three and a half bath, French country home features a large double-height living room with fireplace, newly renovated eat-in kitchen, and den with a fireplace. L...
    Dawn Murphy ·3 days ago on RealtyWW
  11. Nestled just minutes away from the heart of East Hampton Village, this expansive home is situated on a serene cul-de-sac. Thoughtfully designed, the interior features a welcoming den adorned with a charming window seat, a luminous double-story gre...
    Sotheby's International Realty - ·3 days ago on RealtyWW
  12. Beautiful views of three mile harbor from your water front pool, patio, and living room with fireplace. Enjoy your summer here with walkable access to the harbor bank, take walks in the morning with the swans. Hardwood floors throughout. Primary r...
    Chelsea Blasko ·3 days ago on RealtyWW
  13. Just completed in the highly coveted Amagansett Lanes ~ 6 bedroom 5.5 bath house offers all amenities including all high end furnishings/design by Alicia Murphy Design, outdoor living room with television, heated gunite pool, outdoor kitchen and m...
    Erin Keneally ·3 days ago on RealtyWW
  14. Welcome to 161 Elm Street, a stunning residence exuding timeless elegance in the heart of Southampton village. This renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home boasts 2280 of sq ft living space. The interior features hardwood floors, a home office, and a...
    Tim Morabito ·4 days ago on RealtyWW
  15. Enjoy winding down summer in this newly constructed East Hampton traditional style home! Only minutes from East Hampton Village or downtown Amagansett, off the beach, and relax out back on the sun-lit porch and or cool off on the large grassy lawn...
    Scott Mcginniss ·4 days ago on RealtyWW
Email Alerts

Subscribe to email alerts when new listings show up for this search

Sends email alerts to

SET LOCATION

city
country

(undo)Price

to

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Pets Allowed

Amenities

Square Feet

to

Photo

Refine By Keyword