All Rentals

Apartments for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY

(1 - 15 of 206)
  1. WebID 675159 Beautiful Post State of the art sited on a private and pristine 3.10 acres with gated entry. This summer residence offers ...
    Nest Seekers International ·1 day ago on Nest Seekers
  2. WebID 546616 Sag Harbor 4 beds and a den for additional guests - new bathrooms - just fully updated. Upstairs has large great room, kit...
    Nest Seekers International ·3 days ago on Nest Seekers
  3. 2 beds cottage with living room, dedicated dining area area. Close to village and bay beaches,.
    3 days ago on RENTOCULAR
  4. WebID 70404 Enjoy this Beautiful 3 Beds, 3.5 Bathrooms Home on Glover Street in Sag Harbor Village. This Magnificent Bay Front Home wit...
    Nest Seekers International ·3 days ago on Nest Seekers
  5. WebID 43983 Enjoy this 3 Beds, two Bathrooms Sag Harbor Contemporary with Beautiful Water Views! Sag Harbor Water view Marcy Br...
    Nest Seekers International ·3 days ago on Nest Seekers
  6. WebID 40592 This updated charming and chic two beds beach cottage has evry amenity you need to have a great summer right near the best ...
    Nest Seekers International ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  7. Bright and sunny home in the historic village of Sag on a peaceful and 5 minutes to Main, shops, restaurants, cinema, Bay theater and a n...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  8. WebID 35140 This property is located in the middle of the historic district of Sag Harbor Village. This 2 level/two beds home has one b...
    Nest Seekers International ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  9. WebID 412614 2 level gorgeous home over 4 thousand square feet on an acre of land and an outside pool with spectacular views. Beautiful...
    Nest Seekers International ·3 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  10. 2 beds waterfront condominium in Sag Harbor Village. Deck with barbecue. Community swimming pool and tennis. Minutes to bay beaches and s...
    3 weeks ago on RENTOCULAR
  11. WebID 549022 Enjoy this 4 Beds, 4.5 Bathrooms Immaculate Home with Chefs' Kitchen, Sunroom and Heated Gunite Pool. Just moments to the ...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  12. WebID 411279 This amazing Chateau offers five beds and 4 and a half baths. This two acre property has gorgeous views of the water as we...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  13. WebID 73241 This sweet Sag Harbor home is the perfect summer getaway or year round rental. This house offers three beds, two and half b...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  14. WebID 48431 This amazing contemporary house is located in the heart of Water Mill on almost an acre. The house offers over 3700 sq-ft o...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  15. WebID 418841 Enjoy the gorgeous sunsets, go for a walk on the beach or go fishing at this 2 beds, two bathrooms beach-front cottage. ...
    Posted on Nest Seekers








Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .