All Rentals

Apartments for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY

(1 - 15 of 167)
  1. WebID 45433 Peaceful location in North Haven on destination street surrounded by gated estates. Water access and private beach at the e...
    Nest Seekers International ·1 day ago on Nest Seekers
  2. Our building is located at 148 Suffolk Street, Sag Harbor, 11963, NY Monthly rental rates range from $7062 We have 2 beds units available...
    RentLingo Manager ·3 days ago on RentLingo
  3. WebID 46706 Beutifully updated and delightful light filled home to spend your vacation in. Great room with cathedral ceilings and firep...
    Nest Seekers International ·4 days ago on Nest Seekers
  4. WebID 617903 With a pool house and heated pool this centrally located barn is close to ocean beaches, shops and restaurants. Featuring ...
    Nest Seekers International ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  5. WebID 614766 This amazing cape offers 3 beds, 1.5 bathrooms and a heated pool. In iconic Sag Harbor this is the perfect summer getaway....
    Nest Seekers International ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  6. WebID 542449 Magnificent State of the art Home overlooking Long Beach! Finest Appointments throughout including Bamboo Floors, Great Ro...
    Nest Seekers International ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  7. There are o y 5 homes in the Sag Historic District resting on a full acre and this is the crown jewel! Set back nearly twenty yards from ...
    Ann Marsh ·3 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  8. WebID 611299 Brand new spacious home on the outskirts of Village line in Sag Harbor. HIgh ceiling and generously proportioned rooms wil...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  9. WebID 611301 Spectacular views from this light -filled home, located in a private beach community. The interior features a great room w...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  10. Year-round 1 beds apartment on Captain's Row is located in the historic village of Sag Harbor. The space is on the 2nd floor of this circ...
    Posted on
  11. WebID 610033 Beautiful contemporary home on 1.7 +/- acres with 607 feet of private waterfront, complete with a dock that can accommodat...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  12. Very spacious updated 3 beds unit on Suffolk St and Houston. in Lower East Side, a prime location with a live-in super. Unit renovations ...
    Posted on Apartable
  13. WebID 609522 This roomy ranch is located near the bay beaches and convenient to both Bridgehampton and Sag Harbor. The indoor living sp...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  14. WebID 606235 This four beds, 3 bathrooms Saltbox is ideally situated on a pretty cul-de-sac street and just minutes from downtown Sag H...
    Posted on Nest Seekers
  15. This inspired renovation of a 19th C. home is, in a word, divine. Fully restored by Farrin Cary Design, the fresh state of the art interi...
    Posted on Featured Rentals








Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .