All Rentals
Ask Search Post

Apartments for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY

(1 - 15 of 161)
  1. Pool guest house with room for 2 + full size bathroom,. Main house has three beds, 2 1 two bathrooms, large sunny living room with firepl...
    Olive Reid ·1 day ago on Featured Rentals
  2. Our building is located at 148 Suffolk Street, Sag Harbor, 11963, NY Monthly rental rates range from $7062 We have 2 beds units available...
    RentLingo Manager ·1 day ago on RentLingo
  3. Designer's own, super-stylish, just up-to-date, state of the art-ranch-style beach house in, offers water views from almost every window,...
    Tommie Diaz ·1 day ago on Featured Rentals
  4. WebID 604165 This three beds cottage in Sag Harbor is conveniently located close to Long Beach and Sag Harbor Village. Large sunny yard...
    Elizabeth Yennie (Nest Seekers ·2 days ago on Nest Seekers
  5. Is this beautifully restored 1870s Townhouse. The main house offers 3 beds, two bathrooms, spacious living room, and kitchen with eating ...
    Janie French ·1 week ago on Featured Rentals
  6. WebID 600482 This totally up-to-date and restored rental is in the heart of Sag Harbor Village. With the bay on 1 end of the street and...
    Elizabeth Yennie (Nest Seekers ·1 week ago on Nest Seekers
  7. WebID 36826 Cottage in private community with wood burning stove, outdoor shower, 760 square ft elevated deck and private boat rights. ...
    Maz Crotty (Nest Seekers International) ·1 week ago on Nest Seekers
  8. Recently remodeled with lots of original information and classic appeal featuring 4 beds, two bathrooms, living room, dining area, 4JC9EZ...
    Judith Shelton ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  9. Have the best summer in this 5 beds, four bathrooms "Arts and Crafts" front home, right in the 4JC9Q3 village of Sag. Open living plan, c...
    Paula Young ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  10. Beautiful Cove water views. Double height windowed living room, spacious dedicated dining area room with sliders to deck, kitchen with ea...
    Kim Gilbert ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  11. This 3 beds, 1. five Bathrooms Beach Cottage is minutes to Sag Village and all Bay Beaches. Multi level decking offers 4JC95B waterside e...
    Willie Logan ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  12. Charming 3 beds home in a lovely waterfront community 4JC9QZ with outdoor shower and pool. Waterfront community.
    Paula Young ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  13. Enjoy the month in this recently updated, 4 beds, 4. five bathrooms traditional. Located just outside Sag Village in a peaceful community...
    Fred Coleman ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  14. Stylish Sag home with upscale finishes and furnishings to relax and enjoy the summer. French 4JC317 doors to the backyard overlooking the...
    Kim Gilbert ·2 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  15. WebID 596753 This stylish traditional home over 6500 square ft set on 2 very private acres in and exclusive North Haven community has e...
    Maz Crotty (Nest Seekers International) ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers








Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .