All Rentals
Ask Search Post

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 199)
  1. Sleek water front on ram islandthis fabulous waterfront property on big ram island area of shelter island has dramatic views of gardiner'...
    Marketplace User ·1 day ago on Hotpads.com
  2. Shelter island traditional with poolthis spacious 4 beds, three bathrooms home is sited on a hill surrounded by lovely flowering gardens.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  3. Stylish farmhouse with poolbuilt in 1884 and totally up-to-date in 2010, this centrally located farmhouse features 4 beds, 3.5 bathrooms,...
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  4. Waterview colonial with five beds and poolbeautifully refurbished 6 beds home with view of dering harbor.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  5. Beautiful traditional overlooking dering harboran incredible property with everything you need for a fantastic summer vacation.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  6. Gated colonial on 1.8 acres with poolbeautiful, newly furnished 4 beds, 4.5 bathrooms home located on a private, park like, beautifully l...
    Marketplace User ·2 days ago on Hotpads.com
  7. Shelter island sunset waterviewsaround the bend from sunset beach, perlman music camp, quinipet sailing.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  8. Shelter island heights victorian waterfrontbeautifully restored victorian on dering harbor with 4 beds, four bathrooms, living room, musi...
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  9. Westmoreland waterfront with poolwith just over 100ft of waterfront and located at the end of a peaceful street in westmoreland farm, thi...
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  10. Shelter island premier waterfrontyou must see this amazing restoration of a classic victorian-era grand carriage house on a most beautifu...
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  11. Summer days by the sea on shelter islandwake up each morning to beautiful views of peconic bay.
    Marketplace User ·2 days ago on Hotpads.com
  12. Delightful contemporary with poollocated on private beautifully landscaped acre between wades beach and fresh pond.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  13. Shelter island waterview with poolbordering golf course and overlooking gardiner's bay.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  14. Waterfront pool houseenjoy romantic views of the twinkling lights of the south ferry from the dining porch of this 4 beds three bathrooms...
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com
  15. Shelter island contemporary with pool and tennisspacious 5 beds, three bathrooms home has it all for your ideal vacation.
    Marketplace User ·3 days ago on Hotpads.com

SET LOCATION

city
country

(undo)Bedrooms

Price

to

Bathrooms

Pets Allowed

Amenities

Square Feet

to

Refine By Keyword

Important
Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .