All Rentals
Ask Search Post

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 224)
  1. This historic 1900's conversion brick farm house located in Shorewood Farm is hidden away at the end of a private lane. Spacious 2 level ...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·2 days ago on LinkURealty
  2. Walk to Shelter Island's Wades Beach from this completely up-to-date and fresh summer rental . Fun kitchen with all new appliances, comfo...
    Marketplace User ·4 days ago on
  3. This stunning well-appointed waterfront home in Shelter Island has every state of the art amenity. Open chef's kitchen leads to outdoor p...
    Marketplace User ·4 days ago on
  4. Open floor plan with abundant natural light, cathedral ceilings and ebony wood floors create a comfortable living area. Wrap around porch...
    Marketplace User ·4 days ago on
  5. Located at the top of Shelter Island Heights with a peek-a-boo waterview, this gracious turn of the century home enjoys many lovely Victo...
    Marketplace User ·6 days ago on
  6. Listed with M. Wein Realty, Inc., for more info, please visit out web siteat or call 631-749-XXXX. Perfectly located...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on Postlets operated by Zillow
  7. Perfectly located within a stones throw to Crescent Beach, SI golf Course, tennis, sailing and the center of the Heights. A well maintain...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  8. Pristine and sunny contemporary with views over creek out to North Haven. House has four beds, 2 baths, dock, association tennis and beac...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  9. Charming farmhouse with state of the art touches, featuring 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms, state of the art kitchen, large deck with grill for en...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·1 week ago on LinkuRealty
  10. Deeded Boat Slip In Smith Cove up to 25 ft boat. Totally updated 4 beds, two bathrooms cape on cleared half acre in private beach and boa...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  11. All inclusive rental. Nicely located across from Sachem's Wood Preserve, this smartly styled home has three beds, 2 bathrooms, an open pl...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  12. SHELTER ISLAND-The 1950 Cape with 1954 square ft under roof has been updated and has four BEDROOMs and 2 full Bathrooms. The wood floors ...
    1 week ago on
  13. Listed with M. Wein Realty, Inc. Please call 631-749-XXXX for more Info, and to schedule an appointment. This beautifully maintained and...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on Postlets operated by Zillow
  14. Nestled along the shoreline of Coecles Harbor is a chic facing beach home with guest house. At the end of a long driveway, through the ga...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·2 weeks ago on LinkuRealty
  15. HAY BEACH: Beautiful, newly built farmhouse with all the state of the art amenities. four beds, 3 bathrooms, chef?s kitchen, large deck, ...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on Postlets operated by Zillow







Pets Allowed


Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .