All Rentals

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 201)
  1. This immaculate 4 beds three bathrooms contemporary with southwest overtones has an open design with terra cotta floors, high ceilings an...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  2. Immaculately maintained this lovely 2 level cottage is perfect for a summer stay (one or 2 months and maybe off season). Step into the gr...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·1 week ago on LinkuRealty
  3. 4+ bedrooms, 4 bathrooms home in peaceful Hilo Shores Community with shared dock. Recently updated and landscaped with front porch, back ...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  4. On a beautiful bluff overlooking Gardiner's Bay, this bright, open 5 beds, four bathrooms shingle style Shelter Island home offers every ...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  5. Stunning 5 beds, 3.5 bathrooms farmhouse style home is sited high on a hill in the lovely Hilo Shores area of Shelter Island. Featuring a...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  6. Beautifully updated 4 beds, five bathrooms home on 1.02 acres in Hilo Shores with sunny Southern exposure, pool and dock. Featuring a lar...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  7. Located in the prestigious village of Dering Harbor, this attractive and beautifully decorated home features 5 beds, 3.5 bathrooms, butle...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  8. WADES BEACH CHARMER: Step back into 1700s Shelter Island while having the state of the art amenities of today. This beautifully restored ...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on Postlets operated by Zillow
  9. 1st time available for rent! This newly remodeled 5 beds, three bathrooms waterfront compound is the perfect summer retreat. Located on o...
    2 weeks ago on Listanza
  10. Walk to Shelter Island's Wades Beach from this completely renovated and fresh summer rental . Fun kitchen with all new appliances, comfor...
    2 weeks ago on Listanza
  11. One of the most prestigious areas on Shelter Island. three master en suites, two additional guest rooms, 4.5 baths, great room with bar w...
    2 weeks ago on Listanza
  12. Open floor plan with abundant natural light, high ceilings and ebony wood floors create a comfortable living area. Wrap around porch, gun...
    2 weeks ago on Listanza
  13. Beautiful and well maintained 4 beds three bathrooms home with heated pool ready for your summertime enjoyment. Walk to the beach or sit ...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  14. Convenient to beach and boating. This four beds, 2.5 bathrooms summer getaway has an open floor plan, lovely yard and 36 feet x 18 ft hea...
    Posted on
  15. Located within a stones throw of Heights restaurants, shops, tennis, golf, marina, ferry and transportation to NYC with 4 beds, two full ...
    Posted on







Pets Allowed

Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .