All Rentals

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 235)
  1. Down a private road on West Neck Creek, this home features 4 beds, three bathrooms, large eat-in-kitchen, dining room open to large livin...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·1 hour ago on LinkURealty
  2. This spacious contemporary is surrounded by nature, close to the beach and ready for summer fun. There are 4 BEDROOMs, two BATHROOMs (bun...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·1 hour ago on LinkURealty
  3. Facing west for sunsets over the water, beautiful seaside covered front porch, 4 beds, two bathrooms, summer breezes, open floor plan wit...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·1 hour ago on LinkURealty
  4. This romantic carriage house is filled with character from days gone by, with state of the art day amenities, and features 4 beds, three ...
    Marketplace User ·1 day ago on
  5. Spacious Colonial with 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms, dining area, living room and great room with patio doors out to deck and heated pool. Close...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·1 week ago on LinkuRealty
  6. Private drive to large waterfront parcel on Lake in Bucolic setting, newly remodeled incredible State of the art Beach House has three wa...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on Postlets operated by Zillow
  7. One of the most prestigious areas on Shelter Island. three master en suites, two additional guest rooms, 4.5 baths, great room with bar w...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  8. This beautifully updated 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms home with brand new gunite pool on a lovely treed acre has a spacious open floor plan that...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  9. Mid Century State of the art in design, this 4 beds home features a sophisticated open floor plan with a wall of glass looking out across...
    Marketplace User ·3 weeks ago on
  10. Built in 1884 and totally up-to-date in 2010, this centrally located farmhouse features 4 beds, 3.5 bathrooms, central air conditioning, ...
    Marketplace User ·3 weeks ago on
  11. Spacious 5 Beds, 3.5 bathrooms home in the Silver Beach area of Shelter Island. Located on a wooded acre on Wheeler Canal with beautiful ...
    Marketplace User ·3 weeks ago on
  12. Ft Home With Gunite Heated Saline Pool With Brick Patios, Cabana, And Outdoor Fireplace. This Home Is New And Beautifully Furnished For Y...
    Nancy Patterson ·3 weeks ago on Featured Rentals
  13. Updated in 2014, this house is as comfortable as it is stylish. This very attractive house has 4 beds and 3 bathrooms on two story. There...
    Posted on
  14. This sleek Bauhaus-inspired classic has sky-high views to Connecticut, sunsets, and offers 4 spacious beds including a master suite with ...
    Posted on
  15. Bordering golf course and overlooking Gardiner's Bay. Sunny and spacious 5 beds, 2.5 bathrooms contemporary offers a 2nd floor living roo...
    Posted on







Pets Allowed


Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .