All Rentals

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 229)
  1. Located on a peaceful lane just a close-by from a sandy beach and town landing, this gracious 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms farmhouse is on two g...
    Marketplace User ·5 hours ago on
  2. Spectacular harbor views from this spacious four beds, 3 bathrooms waterfront contemporary. Everything for an enjoyable summer vacation i...
    Marketplace User ·1 week ago on
  3. Perfectly located within a stones throw to Crescent Beach, SI golf Course, tennis, sailing and the center of the Heights. A well maintain...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·1 week ago on LinkuRealty
  4. Sited off the road on a hill is this lovely four beds, 3 bathrooms home with great outdoor space. Located on a lovely acre beautifully la...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·2 weeks ago on LinkuRealty
  5. Enjoy all the Heights has to offer with this remodeled farmhouse located just a few steps from restaurants, shops, ferry and beach club. ...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  6. This Shelter Island beach house has all the necessary ingredients for a fabulous summer getaway. Located on a shy acre just outside the V...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·2 weeks ago on LinkURealty
  7. Imaginatively designed Octagon by Architect George Knafo with wide front entry, skylit open floor plan, wood burning fireplace and multip...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  8. Completely restored 1890 Victorian has been tastefully done with high end appliances. There is an abundance of natural light that flows t...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  9. Enchanting Magnolia Cottage 1807 up-to-date farmhouse with a fabulous location minutes from Crescent Beach, golf course and Shelter Islan...
    Marketplace User ·3 weeks ago on
  10. This romantic carriage house is filled with character from days gone by, with state of the art day amenities, and features 4 beds, three ...
    Posted on
  11. Spacious Colonial with 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms, dining area, living room and great room with patio doors out to deck and heated pool. Close...
    Posted on LinkuRealty
  12. Private drive to large waterfront parcel on Lake in Bucolic setting, recently remodeled incredible State of the art Beach House has three...
    Posted on Postlets operated by Zillow
  13. One of the most prestigious areas on Shelter Island. three master en suites, two additional guest rooms, 4.5 baths, great room with bar w...
    Posted on
  14. This beautifully updated 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms home with brand new gunite pool on a lovely treed acre has a spacious open floor plan that...
    Posted on
  15. Mid Century State of the art in design, this 4 beds home features a sophisticated open floor plan with a wall of glass looking out across...
    Posted on







Pets Allowed

Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .