All Rentals
Ask Search Post

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 188)
  1. Beautiful victorian swimming-pool home in historic shelter island heights.
    M. Wein Realty ·5 days ago on LinkURealty
  2. This shelter island beach house has all the necessary ingredients for a fabulous year-round getaway.
    Marketplace User ·3 weeks ago on
  3. Shelter island-historic farmhouse on idyllic shelter island conveniently located near a public golf course, popular beach, dining, game r...
    3 weeks ago on
  4. Shelter island-perfect summer retreat. This light and bright contemporary waterfront home with sandy beach offers a private master bedroo...
    3 weeks ago on
  5. Shelter island - 3 baths - 4 beds - convenient location.
    Marketplace User ·3 weeks ago on RealRentals
  6. A Beautiful,four Beds Guest House In A Stunning, Private And Very Scenic Setting. Community pool And Patio Use (Respectfully).
    Posted on New York Times Realestate
  7. Sited off the road on a hill is this lovely four beds, 3 bathrooms home with great outdoor space.
    Posted on LinkuRealty
  8. A classic victorian carriage house fully up-to-date with expansive lawn.
    Posted on LinkuRealty
  9. Shelter island heightsfirst time listing! Located in the highest part of shelter island heights, this home offers 6 beds, 4.5 baths, a gu...
    Posted on
  10. $35,000 june 1-30th $55,000 july 1-31st this incredible property on shelter island sits on a serene and private park like estate of 3.6 a...
    Posted on
  11. Charming farmhouse with poollocated across from fresh pond and within close proximity of wades beach is this custom built farmhouse.
    Posted on
  12. Lovely summer cottagethree bedroom, one bathrooms lovely summer cottage available for rent by the week.
    Posted on
  13. $30,000 july 1-31st $35,000 august 1st to labor day 1st time available for rent!
    Posted on
  14. Shelter island beach-front contemporarybeautiful contemporary home with 4 beds two of which are ensuite, two full and two half baths, a s...
    Posted on
  15. Coecles harbor waterfront with pool and dockcharmingly updated 1916 farmhouse on a lovely, private 1.5 acre parcel on shelter island's be...
    Posted on







Pets Allowed


Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .