All Rentals
Ask Search Post

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 71)
  1. Contemporary home on a private 1/2 acre with a large high ceiling, open floor plan with fireplace, and a large deck with heated gunite pool.
    Marketplace User ·5 hours ago on
  2. Ward's point - among shelter island's most sought after neighborhoods: newly built 4 beds, 3.5 bathrooms home in beautiful shorewood farm...
    Marketplace User ·5 days ago on
  3. In the heart of dering harbor village this classic victorian home offers all the state of the art amenities, including a fully-equipped k...
    Marketplace User ·5 days ago on
  4. Beautifully landscaped for ultimate privacy and set behind iron gates, this new to the market rental is a must see.
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·1 week ago on LinkURealty
  5. This charming carriage house sits off the beaten path within a rolling pastoral setting.
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  6. This fully remodeled vacation home is less than 1000 ft from shelter islands renowned silver beach.
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  7. This state of the art vacation rental is clean and up-to-date.
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  8. One of the most prestigious areas on shelter island.
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  9. Sparkling traditional on fresh pond provides a great summer vacation opportunity.
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·3 weeks ago on LinkURealty
  10. This stylish cottage on big ram has forever water views, great sandy beach, open floor plan and outdoor dining atop the waterfront bluff.
    Posted on LinkuRealty
  11. Located in a woodland setting this four beds, 3 bathrooms contemporary features a beautiful living space with high ceiling and stone fire...
    Posted on LinkURealty
  12. This lovely classic 1860's waterfront home features 6 beds, 4.5 bathrooms, formal living space, dedicated dining area room with views of ...
    Posted on LinkURealty
  13. Two acre private oasis. Main house has living room, dedicated dining area room, kitchen, three beds, 2 bathrooms plus there is a separate...
    Posted on
  14. Walk to town landing, shopping from this 4 beds, four bathrooms country home. Large living room, eat-in-kitchen, enclosed porch and sunny...
    Posted on LinkURealty
  15. Charming 6 beds, 3.5 bathrooms home overlooking dering harbor, featuring living room, country kitchen with butler's kitchen, breakfast ro...
    Posted on LinkuRealty


Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .