All Rentals
Ask Search Post

Four Plus Bedroom Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

(1 - 15 of 80)
  1. Situated in the west neck area, this farmhouse sited on 1.30 acres is set back from the road, tuck away behind rich and lush forsythia pr...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·4 days ago on LinkURealty
  2. Webid 63767 this incredible property on shelter island sits on a serene and private park like estate of 3.6 acres.
    Maz Crotty (Nest Seekers International) ·4 days ago on Nest Seekers
  3. Webid 58706 stylish contemporary home in hay beach area of beautiful shelter island.
    Maz Crotty (Nest Seekers International) ·2 weeks ago on Nest Seekers
  4. Just a stones throw from silver beach, this recently remodeled 4 beds, three bathrooms home features a heated in-ground pool, tennis cour...
    Marketplace User ·2 weeks ago on
  5. This immaculately kept home features 4 beds, four bathrooms, living room, open-plan kitchen, large library/ study that can also be used a...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·2 weeks ago on LinkuRealty
  6. Nestled along the shoreline of coecles harbor is a chic facing beach home with guest house.
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·3 weeks ago on LinkURealty
  7. Charming farmhouse with state of the art touches, featuring 4 beds, 2.5 bathrooms, state of the art kitchen, large deck with grill for en...
    Posted on LinkURealty
  8. Grand entrance and room for the entire family, 142' water frontage with a deep water private dock.
    Posted on
  9. Crossing the front threshold 1 is overcome by the panoramic water and north shore views.
    Posted on LinkuRealty
  10. Sited on the highest elevation on shelter island. This 5 beds contemporary home provides panoramic sunset water views from every room, in...
    Posted on LinkURealty
  11. Contemporary home on a private 1/2 acre with a large high ceiling, open floor plan with fireplace, and a large deck with heated gunite pool.
    Posted on
  12. In the heart of dering harbor village this classic victorian home offers all the state of the art amenities, including a fully-equipped k...
    Posted on
  13. Ward's point - among shelter island's most sought after neighborhoods: newly built 4 beds, 3.5 bathrooms home in beautiful shorewood farm...
    Posted on
  14. Beautifully landscaped for ultimate privacy and set behind iron gates, this new to the market rental is a must see.
    Posted on LinkURealty
  15. This charming carriage house sits off the beaten path within a rolling pastoral setting.
    Posted on








Square Feet



Refine By Keyword

Safety Tips
  • Always see the place in person before renting.
  • Be cautious of people claiming to be overseas.
  • Don’t wire money or take advance payments.

To learn more, visit the Safety Center. Report suspicious listings by clicking on .

Zeroboxer by Fonda Lee. The new action-packed science fiction novel, on sale now.